Climate.ruthner.at← ruthner.atWeather Amstetten →DEEN

Conclusion, positions and further sources

What can be said from the data, and what cannot? Here the statement of the IPCC and the most frequent objections stand side by side, together with further sources and counter-positions.

How to read: Measurement measured values · Reconstruction from indirect data such as ice or tree rings · Model computer model · Own calculation calculated by me from raw data. Technical terms are explained in the glossary.

07 — Conclusion

What can be said from the climate data – and what cannot

It has become warmer. Since 1979 the sea surface temperature (60°S–60°N) has risen by about 0.12 °C and that of the global air by about 0.19 °C per decade (HadCRUT5). The maps show this on land and sea; over large areas the warmest year has only been since 2015.

On average, the models run warmer than the measurement. Of the 41 calculated climate models (one run each, scenario SSP2-4.5), most have warmed more strongly than the measurement since 1979 (sea: 35 of 41, air: 32 of 41). The range between the models is large (sea 0.11 to 0.26, air 0.14 to 0.42 °C per decade). How large the difference is depends on the selection: with the same quantity (blended model quantity) and only models within the IPCC range of climate sensitivity, the model mean of the air temperature, at 0.18 °C per decade, is close to the measurement (0.19); for the sea surface a difference remains (0.14 versus 0.12).

CO₂ has risen, and humans emit more than ends up in the air. The concentration rose from about 278 to around 426 ppm. Since 1850 about 751 billion t of carbon have been emitted, of which 39% stayed in the air, the rest went into sea and plants. The annual natural exchange is much larger than the human share (about 5%).

What a single country changes is tiny in the calculation. Austria emits about 0.14% of the world’s CO₂. Using the IPCC assumption (0.45 °C per 1,000 billion t CO₂), a 30% reduction by 2100 results in about 0.0006 °C less warming. The estimated costs are given in the CO₂ section, tab “Countries & scenarios”.

The long time spans show fluctuations. In the Vostok ice core, temperature and CO₂ rise and fall together over four glacial cycles, with CO₂ lagging the temperature by roughly 1,000 years on average. Over the last 2,000 years there were warm and cold phases (Roman and Medieval Warm Periods, Little Ice Age). Whether temperature is rising faster today than before depends on the time period and on the temporal resolution of the data.

What the page does not show: The page’s own data analyses alone do not provide complete proof of the causes. For the scientific assessment the results of the IPCC and further research are therefore used in addition. The model selection (in the main charts one run per model and one scenario; multiple runs and further scenarios are in the “For specialists” block), the data situation before 1900 and the calculation assumptions are explained in the expandable notes. The IPCC statement and the objections to it are in the section “Positions”.

08 — Positions

Warm, yes – but what is the cause?

The climate data on this page show that it is getting warmer, not why on their own. Here the statement of the IPCC and the most common objections to it are set side by side, each with sources.

Positions and opposing positions

Principle of this page: Statements are judged by whether they can be backed up with data, source and calculation method, not by who makes them. This applies to the IPCC as much as to its critics. The page shows the data and links different views; no assessment by the author is given here.

Statement of the IPCC: The warming since 1850 to 1900 is predominantly due to human-made greenhouse gases: in the sixth assessment report (AR6), about 1.07 °C is human-caused (likely range 0.8 to 1.3) against about 1.09 °C observed (each for 2010–2019 relative to 1850–1900), while natural drivers contribute about −0.1 to +0.1 °C (AR6, Summary for Policymakers). Against this stand the following objections, each with the counter-argument:

ObjectionHow it is justifiedWhat is put forward against it
CO₂ follows temperature, not the other way roundHumlum et al. 2013 (a lag of 9 to 12 months in the measurement series), Caillon et al. 2003 (at the end of the ice age about 800 years after the warming began).At the end of the ice ages, CO₂ amplifies a warming that was initially triggered by something else (feedback); this does not contradict the greenhouse effect. Today's CO₂ rise measurably comes from emissions: more is emitted than arrives in the air (see "Amount & origin").
The Sun determines the temperatureConnolly, Soon et al. 2021 (depending on the solar series, from "no influence" to "the largest part"), Svensmark 2015 (cosmic rays and clouds).Solar irradiance has not risen since the 1950s, but temperature has. According to the IPCC, the forcing from the Sun is small compared with that of greenhouse gases. The choice of the solar series decides the result, as the authors themselves state.
Water vapour and clouds act more strongly than CO₂Schmidt et al. 2010 (water vapour about half of the greenhouse effect), Lindzen & Choi 2021 (iris effect), Mauritsen & Stevens 2015.Water vapour amplifies a warming but is controlled by temperature and stays in the air only for days; long-lived gases such as CO₂ provide the trigger. The cloud effect is an open field of research; the IPCC calculates a net amplifying feedback.
Climate sensitivity is lower than in the modelsLewis & Curry 2018 (about 1.7 °C for a doubling of CO₂); the models have run warmer than the measurement on average since 1979 (see charts).The IPCC regards 2.5 to 4 °C as likely, based on several independent lines of evidence (energy budget, palaeoclimate, processes). It gives particularly hot models less weight. Estimates from the energy budget depend on the method.
There have always been warm and cold phasesLjungqvist 2010 (Roman and Medieval Warm Periods, Little Ice Age), Büntgen et al. 2011.Earlier fluctuations had causes (Sun, volcanoes, ocean currents) and show that the climate responds to forcings. In the reconstruction above, the last decades lie above the earlier warm phases; whether the rise is faster than before depends on the period and the resolution (see Time travel).
The media exaggerateEreaut & Segnit 2006 (language analysis of British climate reporting, "alarmism").Exaggerated reporting is possible; it does not change the measurement series. The data situation can be checked independently of it against the raw data, as on this page.

Data as of November 2026. The data series end in different years depending on the source (mostly 2024 or 2025); the end point is given in the source note under each chart, an overview is on “Data and methods”.

Feedback

Values wrong, an idea or a question? The message goes directly to the author of the page. Name and email address are optional and are only used for a reply.